Garlic Jim's Reviews
Garlic Jim's has an overall rating of 3.5 based on 24 reviews. Customer feedback on Garlic Jim's is mixed: Garlic Jim's reviewers highlight positive aspects like delicious garlic knots, fast delivery, friendly customer service, great variety of toppings, which strongly appeal to pizza lovers, families looking for quick meals, garlic enthusiasts, local foodies. However, Garlic Jim's is often criticized for its inconsistent pizza quality, higher prices than competitors, limited gluten-free options, occasional long wait times.
24 reviews
5 Stars
5
4 Stars
5
3 Stars
3
2 Stars
4
1 Star
1
How would you rate Garlic Jim's?
All Garlic Jim's Reviews (24)
CarolynJong
May 28, 2026
"Kinda small portions"
The food was alright, I guess, but the portions felt a bit on the small side. I paid a fair amount and still sort of felt like I needed a snack or something after. The pizza also didn’t seem as loaded as I thought it would be. Not awful or anything, just didn’t really feel worth it for what you get.
0
Reply
RachelGinsburg_91
May 24, 2026
"I grabbed a pizza from Garlic Jim’s last..."
I grabbed a pizza from Garlic Jim’s last weekend on a total impulse, my first bite was like, okay, this is decent. The cheese and sauce tasted fresh, and the crust was solid enough that I kept going back for another slice.
The toppings were where it got a little iffy. Some of the peppers had that nice crunchy bite, but then the mushrooms tasted kind of tired, which threw me off. Not a bad pizza overall, but I definitely wish the veggie freshness was more consistent.
The toppings were where it got a little iffy. Some of the peppers had that nice crunchy bite, but then the mushrooms tasted kind of tired, which threw me off. Not a bad pizza overall, but I definitely wish the veggie freshness was more consistent.
0
Reply
ValentinQuintero_81
May 13, 2026
"Nice savings if you don’t mind checking a few"
I found a decent deal for Garlic Jim’s and ended up saving a few bucks on my order, which felt like the responsible thing to do instead of just paying full price without looking. A couple of the coupons didn’t work, so it took a little trial and error, but I still think it’s worth checking before you order.
0
Reply
Joan_carson92
May 05, 2026
"Pretty smooth pickup, parking was a pain"
I ordered online and stopped by after work to grab it. it was super easy, the pizza was hot, ready to go, and I barely had to wait at all. The staff was friendly enough too, nothing over the top but totally fine. Parking, though, was kind of irritating and made the whole thing feel more stressful than it needed to be. Still, the pizza was good and I’d probably order from there again.
0
Reply
ChristineMathews
May 01, 2026
"Felt a bit pressured and not really worth the price"
The pizza was okay, nothing awful, but I felt like it was overpriced for what you get. The size and toppings didn’t really match the price, and I kind of felt pressured to justify spending that much once I had already ordered. I expected it to be better for the money. I probably wouldn’t order again unless there was a coupon or some kind of deal.
0
Reply
david-Ayers
April 29, 2026
"the main issue was just how late..."
the main issue was just how late the delivery was. The app showed one time, but it ended up taking way longer and I barely got any updates while I was waiting. By the time the food finally got here, I was already annoyed and it didn’t taste as good anymore. Kinda disappointing, probbly won’t order delivery from here again.
0
Reply
alice.Casali
April 25, 2026
"Quality is kinda hit or miss"
I’ve had it be really good one time, then the next time it’s just not the same at all. Idk, feels like the quality changes every order, which is kinda frustrating.
0
Reply
WHITMORE
April 22, 2026
"Good options, but I wanted a little more"
The menu has a decent amount to choose from, especially if you’re in the mood for pizza. They’ve got the usual options, plus a few different toppings that make it a little more interesting. That said, if you’re looking for something outside of pizza, it does feel a bit limited. Overall, it wasn’t a bad experience at all, I just left feeling like I wished there had been a little more variety
0
Reply
Amanda.payne
March 16, 2026
"Order arrived exactly right"
I was happy to see everything in my order was correct and nothing was missing. It’s always reassuring when a company gets the details right, and this definitely made me feel confident ordering from them again.
0
Reply
JoelLittlejohn_76
February 26, 2026
"Tasty pizza that hits the spot"
Overall, I really enjoyed this pizza. It tasted great and the crust had a nice texture, which made it a solid option for an easy meal. My only small complaint is that the crust was a bit salty, but it was still good and satisfying.
0
Reply
michael_Grant86
February 26, 2026
"Helpful, just a little slow"
Customer service was really nice and they did get my issue fixed. It just took a bit longer than I was expecting... but overall, not a bad experience
0
Reply
MILLER
February 20, 2026
"Really good gluten free pizza"
I’ve been really happy with Garlic Jim’s gluten free crust. Like I said, it actually tastes good and doesn’t feel like one of those sad backup options you settle for. I’ve ordered it a couple times now and it’s been solid every time. It’s just nice to have a pizza place where I can get gluten free and, like I said, not feel like I’m missing out
0
Reply
jamie.Cato
February 11, 2026
"Food was still hot when it arrived"
I ordered from Garlic Jim's last night, and for delivery, I was impressed with how hot everything still was when it got to me. The cheese on the pizza was still melty, and the crust held up well instead of turning soggy or cold. The wings were warm too, which depends a lot on the place and how far the driver has to go, but this order came through really well. It’s a simple thing, but it definitely made the meal better. 5 stars from me.
0
Reply
KANG
February 03, 2026
"I ordered dinner through Garlic Jim's and..."
I ordered dinner through Garlic Jim's and, it was actually easy. The menu loaded like it was supposed to, picking toppings didn’t turn into some whole ordeal, and checkout somehow managed not to break or throw random issues at me. I even got the confirmation right away, which was nice. Overall, smooth, which, sadly, feels worth mentioning these days.
0
Reply
StellaBurks
January 16, 2026
"Staff felt a little distant"
I stopped by after a friend recommended the place, but the staff didn’t come across as very warm or friendly. The experience was okay overall, just felt a bit cold compared to what I was expecting.
0
Reply
Richard_roberts72
January 07, 2026
"Toppings were a little skimpy"
The pizza tasted good overall, so I can’t say it was bad, but for what I paid I was expecting a bit more on top and some slices had barely anything on them which was kind of disappointing, I’d probably order again if I was in the mood but I just wish Garlic Jim’s would be a little more generous with the toppings
0
Reply
Michael_hitt74
December 24, 2025
"Pretty much the perfect crust"
The crust was spot on, crispy around the edges but still soft in the middle. I loved it.
0
Reply
JohnRosenbeck_41
December 09, 2025
"Clean enough that I’d go back"
I stopped by Garlic Jim’s and my quick way of judging a place is usually the floor, the tables, and the counter. Everything looked good overall, tables were wiped down, the floor wasn’t sticky, and the counter area seemed organized. The bathroom probably could’ve been checked a little more often, but it wasn’t anything gross. Overall, it felt clean and easy to eat there. I’d give it 4 stars.
0
Reply
Have a question about Garlic Jim's?
Log in to ask your Garlic Jim's question!
Customer Reviews
Ask a Question
